Maysville Museum, Presque Isle

Every now and again, the rehabilitation of a local landmark transforms not only a neighborhood, but an entire community. The creation of the Maysville Museum in Presque Isle is just such a project. One hundred fifty years, ago, Maysville was a small Aroostook County town, on the road between Presque Isle and Caribou. In 1883, Presque Isle annexed the village, which included a two-story school building that also contained Maysville’s Town Office and the Maysville Grange. That building was lost in a fire, as was its successor, but a 1939 structure built by the Grange was occupied until the grange disbanded and its home was sold to the City of Presque Isle. Tragically, that building, too, fell prey to fire after being sold to a private owner, and it was left vacant and exposed to the elements.

Until 2011. That’s the year the Grange building was purchased by the Presque Isle Historical Society. Their new vision for the hall included use as a small museum celebrating the history of education and town management along Maine’s northern frontier, with a specific focus on Maysville’s role in the Aroostook War.

At the time renovations began, much of the southeast corner was exposed to the weather, and animals had made their way into the building. Fire-damaged wood, broken windows and a cracked and collapsing foundation were but a few challenging aspects of the building’s condition, made worse by the fact that no plumbing, septic or well were present.  

Following removal of water-logged insulation and ceiling panels as well as other debris, the building was lifted and an entirely new foundation poured. Other work included new roofing and siding, a new front porch and steps, chimney repairs, sanding and refinishing of original hardwood floors, a new tin ceiling, new windows, and the installation of a heat pump and historic lighting fixtures. Phase Two of the project, which will allow the museum to be open year-round, includes installation of an ADA compliant restroom, a second exit, and a disabled access ramp with a small parking lot beyond.

The Presque Isle Historical Society, an all-volunteer organization, has made an incredible community impact through this project. Prior to the renovation of this building, the group had only a small, two-story Victorian house museum open for once-a-month tours –well off the beaten path on a side street in downtown. The museum’s new location along US Route 1, provides much greater visibility and more opportunity for historic interpretation and educational programming.

Community support for rehabilitation of the building was overwhelming, with all funding for renovations coming either from cash donations from local residents, or from tradesmen volunteering their time and expertise. The completed museum pays tribute to the one-room schoolhouses and meeting places that once connected the communities of Maine, and is a stellar example of community ownership in action.

Samuel P. Grindle House, Castine

The poet Elizabeth Hardwick once said that Castine has a history more convoluted than that of the multi-cultural Danzig Corridor. She had a point. Successively settled by the French, the Dutch and the British, Castine is a town with a remarkable historical and architectural legacy.

In 1850, Samuel P. Grindle, a ship carpenter, purchased a parcel of land fronting the Castine Town Common. The following summer he constructed a house in the Greek Revival style, which remained in private hands until 2008. Today, the house is a significant contributing element to the cultural landscape of the Castine Town Common, recognized as one of Maine’s best surviving examples of a town green. According to the National Register listing of the Castine Historic District, Castine, "is one of the most historic villages on the coast of New England ... the sum total of its parts adds up to an almost undisturbed eighteenth and nineteenth century environment.”

Sadly, by the 1970s Grindle House was no longer a town treasure. Aluminum siding covered original clapboards and pilasters and the original entrance surround had been destroyed. Fine, 19th-century shutters had been removed, windows replaced and chimneys rebuilt. The interior itself was unfit for habitation – there was just one antiquated bathroom, a coal-fired furnace and exposed electrical wiring. Every rain storm created pools of water in the basement. Miraculously, though, the 1850s interior woodwork, floors, doors, stairs, fireplace mantles, hardware and built-in cabinets had all survived.

In 2013, the Castine Historical Society acquired the house, thanks to the generous bequest of Deborah Pulliam who was devoted to the cultural life of Castine and Maine and its historic architecture. The society was desperate for new office and archival space, and the Grindle House turned out to be an ideal location. Working from nineteenth-century photographs and physical evidence, the exterior was restored to its 1850s appearance. The building was raised up and a new reinforced concrete foundation poured, then faced with original stone. Chimneys were rebuilt, six-over-six sash windows and shutters installed, and the original front door surround re-created. New electrical, security, and life-safety systems were also added, and the house brought into full compliance with ADA accessibility standards. The Grindle House also become home to Castine’s first geothermal heating system.

The Grindle House now provides staff offices for the Castine Historical Society as well as a new, state-of-the-art archival facility. The public areas are decorated in 19th-century style with period-inspired wallpapers, carpets, a painted floor cloth and re-created lighting fixtures. The two front parlors and center stair all are decorated following the recommendations of Andrew Jackson Downing who wrote a popular book on the contemporary architecture of the early 19th century. These spaces serve as a gallery with changing exhibits and a comfortable reading room for researchers.

Because of the generosity of Deborah Pulliam, the Castine Historical Society has rehabilitated a highly visible building in the heart of this historic community. Additionally, they have created a hi-tech facility for the care and service of an expanding collection, while also assuming responsibility for the Castine Town Records, which are now available to the public for the first time in a secure professional setting.